Photograph: Container ship.  Photo credit: Cuaderno de Cultura Cientifica

Christian Resources on Trade Policy

Grace Lenahan, What Catholic Social Teaching Says About Trump’s Tariffs on Canada and Mexico. America Magazine | Archive.is, Mar 3, 2025.

For the Catholic social teaching side, it’s hard to see how imposing tariffs on the developing world respects human dignity. Two specific encyclicals deal with tariffs directly. First, in the wake of decolonization in the 1960s, Pope Paul VI’s “Populorum Progressio” emphasizes the importance of just trade relationships (Nos. 58-61). For unequal countries, the market logic of fair trade is not enough. Just as C.S.T. supports minimum wages as a way to ensure that workers are paid enough to respect their dignity, C.S.T. supports just prices in trade relationships to ensure that countries receive enough income to respect their dignity.

In 2009, Pope Benedict XVI’s “Caritas in Veritate” went further. Early on, it mentions high tariffs in rich countries as a problem that hinders the economic development of poor countries. Later on, it invokes the principle of subsidiarity to talk about the most effective forms of international aid. Ideally, we must help the developing world in ways that develop their local economies. Giving those countries access for their goods and services to markets in the developing world is a good way to do that.

My dissertation research has looked at one example of this sort of development: a coffee cooperative in southern Mexico sponsored by the Mexican province of the Jesuits.

We can apply the analysis above to the specific case of a Mexican coffee farmer. One way to help him would be to buy his green coffee at a price higher than the market price. That’s what many fair trade options do. The Jesuits have gone one step further: They have built a facility so that the producers can roast and market their coffee directly in rural Mexico. This method cuts out the middleman. In the short term, both options could provide the same economic gain for the farmer, but in the long term, the second method is better according to C.S.T. because it empowers the community.

It’s hard to see how imposing tariffs on the developing world respects human dignity because global market access is what these countries need, especially countries that are sending us lots of migrants. The president of Mexico, Claudia Sheinbaum, has been vocal in some of the responses to the threat of tariffs on Mexico. One of the things she’s said is, “If even a small percentage of what the United States allocates to war were instead dedicated to building peace and fostering development, it would address the underlying causes of human mobility.”

 
 
 
 

Christian Restorative Justice and Labor: Topics:

Christian Restorative Justice, Business, and Economics: Topics:

Christian Restorative Justice Critique of the Right: Domestic Policy Topics:

Christian Restorative Justice Critique of the Right: Philosophical Influences