proof-philosophy.jpg

Proof: Philosophical Knowledge

 

Photo credits:  Unknown | CC0

 

Introduction

This page highlights philosophical logic that points to some kind of God, although philosophy by itself cannot determine which God that is. For that, we need historical evidence and reasoning.

 

Spotlight

Part 9: What’s the Right Thing to Do? And How Do We Know? looks at why and how Saruman tried to perform utilitarian calculations, while Gandalf received a morality from higher than himself. This episode explores why the heroes believed they needed to commit "folly." They knew they had to try to destroy the Ring. They knew they had to march on Mordor despite overwhelming odds. They knew they had to pity Gollum. The story shows us the big difference between a received (deontological) moral vision vs. a utilitarian calculation of ends and means.

 
 
 

Part 11: How Pagan Virtue Ethics Opens Up to Christian Faith, Hope, and Love shows how the noble pagan search for virtue ethics was a precursor to Christian love, hope, and faith. The Hobbits grow in love: from mere loyalty to the Shire to sacrificial love for all. Eowyn grows in hope: from hoping for a glorious death in battle to hoping that life and love will outlast death and violence. Finrod, and perhaps Andreth too, grow in faith: to believe that Eru must enter into Arda to heal the Marring.

This presentation is relevant to Proof: Love must relate to all humanity, not just our favorite humans, for what gives us the moral authority to limit a virtue like love? Hope of any sort must be founded on evidence. Faith must offer historical and not just literary data to be evaluated.

00:06:43 Pippin and Merry Grow in Love

00:27:00 Eowyn Grows in Hope

00:40:49 Finrod and Andreth Grow in Faith

01:27:40 How Do We Know?

 
 

Proof: Topics:

This section on Proof spotlights Christian faith’s engagement with forms of knowing. Science by itself is supportive but indeterminate as a way of knowing the truth of Christian faith. Philosophy points to some kind of God, or first cause, without being able to go further. History is the primary mode of knowing about Jesus, much like a jury reasoning about the past to determine the proper narrative. Human Personhood highlights our experience of personhood, which corroborates the conclusions of historical investigation about Christian faith and a Christian understanding of human personhood.